ࡱ> (8 / 0LDArialԖe0Ԗ0llDy-a0@ .  @n?" dd@  @@`` bQJENR >C ".@   )*+W-. 23C4 LH9J:CN; =?@ABHIJOS4V4W.`f 0AA 3|PP@<* ʚ;r5ʚ;g47d7d -a0fppp@ <4dddd8))0l y g4PdPd -a0pl p<4BdBd8))0l y0___PPT10 N___PPT90($?  %O  =World Bank  Detailed Methodology for Procurement Country Systems Piloting Program (2007)ZZ )$ ~ Public procurement is the government activity most vulnerable to corruption. OECD (Integrity in Public Procurement, 2007) The multiplicity of rules may have a negative impact on transparency and lead to legal uncertainties and high transaction costs OECD (Bribery in Public Procurement, 2007) Procurement agencies may also purposely use and abuse the regulatory diversity. For instance, they may privilege firms by opting for tendering procedures which require no controls. They may also formulate requirements which favour specific firms and constrain market access to specific suppliers. OECD (Bribery in Public Procurement, 2007)d-M-.--,-*-,-M33)C8D9E:(# "Fails to articulate, maintain, and encourage international best practices Reduces transparency and accountability, increasing potential for corruption Undermines reliability and accessibility of procurement information Decreases protections for bidders in bidding and tendering processesH#(2LME|EPPRFK??Fails to articulate and encourage international best practices@@ *%MReduces transparency and accountability, increasing probability of corruptionNN ,'RUndermines reliability, transparency, and accessibility of procurement informationSS| -(BDecreases protections for bidders in bidding and tendering processCCPP 30  41  I>/)F;VG    0*  1+    62 "Fails to articulate, maintain, and encourage international best practice Reduces transparency and accountability, increasing potential for corruption Undermines reliability and accessibility of procurement information Decreases protections for bidders in bidding and tendering processesP#(2LME|EPP/8:;<=M  0` 33` Sf3f` 33g` f` www3PP` ZXdbmo` \ғ3y`Ӣ` 3f3ff` 3f3FKf` hk]wwwfܹ` ff>>\`Y{ff` R>&- {p_/̴>?" dd@,|?" dd@   " @ ` n?" dd@   @@``PR    @ ` ` p>> (    6x  `}  T Click to edit Master title style! !  0d  `  RClick to edit Master text styles Second level Third level Fourth level Fifth level!     S  00Ɣ ^ `  X*  0˔ ^   Z*  0dД ^ `  Z*B  s *f޽h ? 3380___PPT10.pv Default Design(0 h8(  h  h NB$gkgk v$  $ v* J%%JJoo h NdL$gkgk  7$ $ x* J%%JJood h c $ ?RH  $4 h NN$gkgk  ! $ RClick to edit Master text styles Second level Third level Fourth level Fifth level!     S h Tx[$gkgk v  $ v* J%%JJoo h Te$gkgk  7 $ x* J%%JJooH h 0jB ? 3380___PPT10. A9 0 PH@T(  T T s *#S" `     T 0 @@ R Evaluation and Comments 10 December 2007 Development Finance International, Inc..S(2+(H T 0޽h ? 33___PPT10i.^ En+D='  = @B +  0 bZ(    c $P<$@0  "8$$dH  0޽h ? 33___PPT10. /+D'  = @B DQ' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +D' =%(Dh' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*}%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*)%(D' =%(Dh' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<**S%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*S%(+ 0 @8,(  , , 0 Ps ,$@0 ,Industry  WB Shared Objective: Strengthen the national procurement systems of Bank borrower countries. Concerns: The proposed pilot methodology and process does not meet the standards of the World Bank s current procurement system and 50+ years of improving practices in (i) measuring  equivalence in selection of pilots and (ii) building local capacity. The many loopholes and omissions in the current proposal run counter to, and conflict with, the Bank s strong position against corruption and for increased transparency. ZK ! B , s *f޽h ? 33^V___PPT106.9 ?;+AGD '  = @B D' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +D' =%(Dh' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*,kw%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*,wj%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*,k%(+0 <40(  0 0 0H   ,$D0 >Recommendation: Proposal and tools should be redrawn to preserve and maintain international best practice in procurement The WB should convene a technical working group of world-class experts to develop effective tools to assess a country s adoption and implementation of international best practice in procurement. The working group should include experienced US and European firms who have been actively involved in analysis of the World Bank s country system methodologies and the OECD/DAC s assessment tools and methodologies.  Zj+H 0 0޽h ? 33___PPT10.$9 !h+ksD'  = @B Du' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*0{%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*0|B%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*0C%(+&0  4(  4 4 0/P@7 : 2  4 0   ,$D0 .tBasis for Detailed Comments: World Bank procurement guidelines and Standard Bidding Documents side-by-side with: - Detailed Methodology for Procurement Country Systems Piloting Program, Draft for Consultations and related PowerPoint presentations - OECD/DAC Version 4 Methodology for Assessment of National Procurement Systems (laws and regs only) - CPAR data available (WB website) - Loan agreements where available (limited via WB website data; NCB side letters not available to public) - 2005 Country Systems proposal indicators * Capacity Assessment, Risk Assessment tools/details are not available for review|tZ0U &0K k0U .0K T0PT_% M $ k , T|WH 4 0޽h ? 33___PPT10.e:`D+ Dn'  = @B D)' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*4t%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*4b%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*4c%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*4%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*4 %(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*4!u%(+E  0 7/ (    S YP <$0    0e  {3The 2007 Proposal for Country Systems Pilot Program4(24  H  0޽h ? 33  ___PPT10 .S@C+[W_D* '  = @B D ' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +DA' =%(D' =%(D' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*L%(DA' =%(D' =%(D' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*L%(DA' =%(D' =%(D' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(DA' =%(D' =%(D' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*#%(+8+0+0 +C0 t(  t t 6px h4Start country-level Qualitative Assessment Process55XB t 0D> t 6r  RCPAR action plan implemented? XB t 0D>(  t 6   ROECD/DAC Completed & Validated XB  t 0D>#` `   t 6ȏ@ 0  FComplete OECD/DACRB  t@ s *D> @ XB  t 0D>   t 0C"?#(  8NO 2 t 0,C"?( 9YES 2xB t 0D>C"?  t 6Ԝ ` KReview NCB side letterT t 00(8$ Flowchart 1: Country Level Qualitative Assessment Process (partial only  see Annex 1)(Y 2<xB t 0D>C"? t 6 b.Mandatory score On Critical sub-indicators?// XB t 0D>Y t 6(`  _+Acceptable score on other sub-indicators,, XB t 0D>`   t 08C"?z 9YES 2 t 0PC"? P  9YES 2 t 6h P  X$Country is cleared for equivalency%%2 t 6>$ ,$D02 t 6>x ,$@02 t 6>fP  ,$D0H t 0޽h ? 33^V___PPT106.H;m+} D '  = @B D' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*t%(D' =%(Dh' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*t%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*t%(+#m 0 $$`33TA$(  Tx T c $ `    T 0}` A Currently 2 * T B\S"`? m,$D0 ^(International Procurement Best Practices))B T s *D>pm,$@0B T s *D>p p,$@0B T s *D>p p,$@0B T@ s *D>p m,$@0B  T s *D>mm,$@0  T 0L`Pf,$ 0 XUnder Country Systems Proposal(2  T 0\@ ,$ 0 dICB Guidelines largely omitted*(2  T 0?   ,$0 f UNCITRAL Model Law not reflected*!(2PPPP  T 6"` V  BUNCITRAL Model Law" T 6tu"`P i IWorld Bank ICB Guidelinesdz + T   ,$D02 T 6ٺfC"?'2 T 6ٺfC"?1I2 T 6ٺfC"?+C2 T 6ٺfC"?@2 T 6MfC"?%2 T 6ٺfC"?+2 T 6ٺfC"?  " T 6p"`J@@  s!Standard Bidding Documents (SBDs)""  T 0 ` ,$0 v & the Bank has developed world class standards, bidding documents and selection procedures that maximize the bidding opportunities and provide for a fair and open playing field for all eligible participants - WB Detailed Methodology, p. 5z! T 0 n ,$0 GWTO work on transparency and multilateral guidelines is not considered*H(26 b  T# y &,$D02 T 0fC"? a2 T 0fC"?`82 T 0fC"? 2 T 0fC"?p2 T 6t$fC"?b 2  T 0fC"? " !T 6"` S Z*New York Convention on Foreign Arbitration++ "T 6"` n m Y'WTO Agreement on Government Procurement((dz p n #T y`,$D 02 $T 6ڋfC"?in2 %T 6ڋfC"?p V2 &T 6ڋfC"? @ &2 'T 6ڋfC"?  2 (T 6fC"?p 2 )T 6ڋfC"?+2 *T 6ڋfC"?z b  +T  X ,$D02 ,T 0fC"? a2 -T 0fC"?`82 .T 0fC"? 2 /T 0fC"?p2 0T 6t$fC"?b 2 1T 0fC"?  2T 0 P   ,$0 Standard Bidding Documents waived and replaced by  suggested minimum content bN(2" 3T 6"` L ,$@0  suggested minimum content of bidding documents (OECD)  undefined>D  H T 0޽h ? 33HH___PPT10G.@yB+G_DFD' #= @B DD' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +DY' =%(D' =%(D5' =4@BB B B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*T%(D' =-q6Bplus(out)*<3<*TD5' =4@BB B B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*T%(D' =-q6Bplus(out)*<3<*TD5' =4@BB B B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*T%(D' =-q6Bplus(out)*<3<*TD5' =4@BB B B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*T%(D' =-q6Bplus(out)*<3<*TD5' =4@BB B B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<* T%(D' =-q6Bplus(out)*<3<* TD8' =A@BB BB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*T%(D' =-g6B fade*<3<*TD8' =A@BB BB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*T%(D' =-g6B fade*<3<*TDd' =%(D ' =%(D6' =A@BB BB0B%(D' =-g6B fade*<3<*TD' =1:Bhidden*o3>+B#style.visibility<*T%(D6' =A@BB BB0B%(D' =-g6B fade*<3<*TD' =1:Bhidden*o3>+B#style.visibility<*T%(D8' =A@BB BB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<* T%(D' =-g6B fade*<3<* TD ' =%(D' =%(D' =A@BBBB0B%())))?D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<* T%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*#T%(D' =%(D ' =%(D8' =A@BB BB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*3T%(D' =-g6B fade*<3<*3TD' =A@BBBB0B%())))?D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*2T%(D' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =1:Bhidden*o3>+B#style.visibility<*T%(DY' =4@BB BB%()))D' =-g6B fade*<3<*TD' =1:Bhidden*o3>+B#style.visibility<*T%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*T%(D' =%(DY' =4@BB BB%()))D' =-g6B fade*<3<* TD' =1:Bhidden*o3>+B#style.visibility<* T%(D' =%(DY' =4@BB BB%()))D' =-g6B fade*<3<*TD' =1:Bhidden*o3>+B#style.visibility<*T%(D' =%(D' =%(D' =A@BBBB0B%())))?D' =1:Bhidden*o3>+B#style.visibility<* T%(D' =A@BBBB0B%())))?D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<* T%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*+T%(D' =%(DL' =%(D' =A@BBBB0B%())))?D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*T%(D' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =1:Bhidden*o3>+B#style.visibility<*"T%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*T%(D ' =%(D6' =A@BB BB0B%(D' =-g6B fade*<3<*TD' =1:Bhidden*o3>+B#style.visibility<*T%(D!' =4@BBBB%(D' =,54*3>Bfillcolor=@BPB<*!TD' =1:B solid*a3>Bfill.type<*!TD' =1:B true*]3>Bfill.on<*!TD' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =,54*3>!Bstyle.color='`B@BPB<*!T+D]' =4@BBBB%(D' =,54*3>#Bstroke.color=@BPB<*!TD' =1:B true*a3>Bstroke.on<*!TD*' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?Dq' =.97 BBBBBKM 0 -2.83237E-6 L -0.24583 -0.14358 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBB?D<*!T++0+T0 ++0+T0 ++0+T0 ++0+ T0 ++0+ T0 ++0+ T0 ++0+ T0 ++0+T0 ++0+T0 ++0+T0 ++0+T0 ++0+!T0 ++0+!T0 ++0+"T0 ++0+2T0 ++0+3T0 +F 0 , $ (  r  S X `      0]`,$D0 v"Under the proposal, a pilot country would not be required to: Apply Bank s Standard Bidding Documents to international tenders (2E) Adhere to Bank norms on fraud and corruption and demonstrate a strong anti-corruption enforcement record (12B) Ensure competitively selection of country procurement personnel based upon procurement knowledge and skills (6A) Ensure that compliance auditors are sufficiently informed about procurement to conduct quality audits that contribute to compliance with regular reporting of issues to management (6A) Conduct effective procurement data collection, analysis, reporting (5B) Make Codes of Conduct / Ethics obligatory or enforceable (12G) Disclose procurement system deficiencies until after loan execution (and then only in loan agreements) (n/a) *> 2 2* A3imC9nqH  0޽h ? 33___PPT10.n+|3Dn'  = @B D)' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*e%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*e%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*e%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*e%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(+ 0 $(  r  S [ `     0p,$D0 n Under the proposal, a pilot country would not be required to: Make all procurement information publicly available free of charge and both comprehensive and easy to understand (5A) Specify time frames for disseminating procurement information (invitations, procurement notices or awards) (5A) Use or regulate model tender documents  where documents exist, only a minimum set of clauses is required (2B) Regularly update and make transparent implementing regulations for the country s procurement systems (2A) Possess a procurement manual for contracting entities (2E) Maintain procurement documents in accordance with international standards (6)8> 2I 2* rkje8JqH  0޽h ? 33 ~ ___PPT10^ .`(@+ksD2 '  = @B D ' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*$%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*$%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*9%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*9%(+ 0 6.(  r  S  `     0T,$D0 Under the proposal, a pilot country would not be required to: Expressly state all evaluation criteria and stipulate lowest evaluated cost as the sole award criteria (1F) Provide a clear method for evaluating non-price criteria in goods and works tenders (1F) Specify the amount of time for bid preparation (1E) Supply prospective bidders with all information pertaining to a bid Ensure that all pre-qualified applicants are allowed to bid (2C) Supply all bidders with the record of bid opening and explicitly deny bids received after the close date or not read publicly (1G) Guarantee formal recourse for complaints to an independent body such as the World Bank (1H) Specify in advance in the bid documents how currency and payment will be handled (1E)f> 2 2* hT/ ]~WPqH  0޽h ? 33___PPT10.ѭ@+ D'  = @B De' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*7%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*7{%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*{%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*?%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*?%(D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(+D 0^N0 @@II@(  C  TD o?"6@`NNN?N``  7Public Procurement Legislative and Regulatory Framework.87F  A  T$ o?"6@`NNN?N``: 5Existence of Implementing Regulations / Documentation.65F  G  T o?"6@`NNN?N:``Z ;Public Procurement System Integrated with Governance System.<;F  6  T o?"6@`NNN?NZ``z t*Country has a Functioning Regulatory Body.+*F  ;  T o?"6@`NNN?Nz`` y/Existence of Institutional Development Capacity.0/F  F  T o?"6@`NNN?N``  :Country Procurement Operations and Practices are Efficient.;:F  ;  T o?"6@`NNN?N ``  y/Functionality of the Public Procurement Market.0/F  ?  T   o?"6@`NNN?N ``  }3Existence of Contract Admin. and Dispute Resolution.43F  ;  T  o?"6@`NNN?N ``  y/Country has Effective Control and Audit Systems.0/F  ,  T  o?"6@`NNN?N ``@ j Efficiency of Appeals Mechanism.! F  ,  T  o?"6@`NNN?NP``` j Degree of Access to Information.! F  D  Tp   o?"6@`NNN?N``` 8Country has in place Ethics and Anticorruption Measures .98F    BfoC"?  41a  BLoC"?  41b  BHfoC"?  41c  BfoC"?0 P  41d  BfoC"?  41e  B$foC"?  41f  B`(foC"? @  41g  B<,foC"?p  41h  B0f3oC"? : 82a  B3f3oC"?Pp: 82b  B73oC"?`: 42c  B;3oC"?: 42d  B?f3oC"?: 82e  BdCf3oC"?: 42f  B@GfoC"?@` 83a  BKfoC"?: Z 83b  BNfoC"?:PpZ 83c  BRfoC"?:Z 83d  BVfoC"?Z z 84a ! BZoC"?Zz 44b " Bh^foC"?ZPpz 84c # BDbfoC"?Zz 84d $ B ffoC"?z 45a % BifoC"?z  85b & BmfoC"?zPp 85c ' BqfoC"?z 85d ( BufoC"?   86a ) BlyfoC"?Pp  86b * BH}foC"?  46c + B$foC"?  86d , Bf3oC"?    87a - B܈f3oC"? Pp  87b . B3oC"?   47c / Bf3oC"?   >7d/ 9e 0 BpfoC"?   48a 1 BLfoC"?   48b 2 B(foC"? `  48c 3 BfoC"?   49a 4 BfoC"?    49b 5 BoC"? Pp  49c 6 BfoC"?   89d 7 BtfoC"? @ 510a 8 BPfoC"?  @ 510b 9 B,foC"? ` @ 510c : BfoC"? Pp@ 910d ; BfoC"? @ 910e < BoC"?P` 511a = Bf3oC"?` 512a > Bxf3oC"?`  512b ? BTf3oC"?``  512d @ B0f3oC"?`Pp 912e A B f3oC"?`  512f B Bf3oC"?` 912g C B3oC"?`  512c D <fC"?   < Requires 3   E 6|S"`?  o'Requires 2 + Capacity Development Plan*,(  F <fC"?  @ Requires 2   G 6S"`?0p \*OECD/DAC Tool vis--vis 2005 WB Proposal++ H s *  j* Set forth in Loan Agreement only; no methodology for monitoring; consequences for non-compliance uncleark 2k f2 I 6>0  p ,$D0H  0޽h ? 33___PPT10n.@+OkDB'  = @B D' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +D4' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*I%(+ 0^N0 49,9BB8(    6C"?2,$DA 0  0C"?2,$D@ 0 B2005 proposal: Withdrawn amidst concerns that procurement standards were  set too low by making only 35% sub-indicators  mandatory 2007 proposal: While 40% of sub-indicators now require  full compliance for country systems pilot program eligibility, some have been downgraded, others watered down. Many are less rigorous than WB s ICB. zWf 2 1 f  BfoC"?  41a  B0oC"?  41b  BfoC"?  41c  BfoC"?0 P  41d  B4foC"?  41e  BfoC"?  41f  B foC"? @  41g  B$foC"?p  41h  Bd(f3oC"? : 82a  B@,f3oC"?Pp: 82b  B03oC"?`: 42c  B33oC"?: 42d  B7f3oC"?: 82e  B;f3oC"?: 42f  B?foC"?@` 83a  BhCfoC"?: Z 83b  BDGfoC"?:PpZ 83c  B KfoC"?:Z 83d  BNfoC"?Z z 84a  BRoC"?Zz 44b  BVfoC"?ZPpz 84c  BZfoC"?Zz 84d  Bl^foC"?z 45a  BHbfoC"?z  85b  B$ffoC"?zPp 85c  BjfoC"?z 85d  BmfoC"?   86a  BqfoC"?Pp  86b  BufoC"?  46c ! BpyfoC"?  86d " BL}f3oC"?    87a # B(f3oC"? Pp  87b $ B3oC"?   47c % Bf3oC"?   >7d/ 9e & BfoC"?   48a ' BfoC"?   48b ( BtfoC"? `  48c ) BPfoC"?   49a * B,foC"?    49b + BoC"? Pp  49c , BfoC"?   89d - BfoC"? @ 510a . BfoC"?  @ 510b / BxfoC"? ` @ 510c 0 BTfoC"? Pp@ 910d 1 B0foC"? @ 910e 2 B oC"?P` 511a 3 Bf3oC"?` 512a 4 Bf3oC"?`  512b 5 Bf3oC"?``  512d 6 B|f3oC"?`Pp 912e 7 BXf3oC"?`  512f 8 B4f3oC"?` 912g 9 B3oC"?`  512c : <fC"?   < Requires 3   ; 6S"`?  d&Requires 2 + Capacity Development Plan"'  < <dfC"?  @ Requires 2  r = B@f33Ԕ0  ,$D;0 >  > 6Ԕ `>P,$@80 ? 0C"?,$:0 940% 2 @ 0dC"? >w ,$90 960% 2 A 0C"?  ,$?0 8OR 2 B 60S"`?0p a/Check OECD/DAC Tool Against WB Rated Indicators00H  0޽h ? 33( ___PPT10.@+܇uDD' H = @B D' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +D' =%(%(Dx' =%(D8' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?D' =.G7 BBBBBYM 3.33333E-6 -2.96296E-6 L 0.03333 0.18773 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB<B=<*D8' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?D' =.G7 BBBBBYM 5.55112E-17 -2.96296E-6 L 0.03333 0.1875 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB<B=<*D8' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?D' =.G7 BBBBBYM -3.33333E-6 -2.96296E-6 L 0.03334 0.1875 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB<B=<*D8' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?D' =.G7 BBBBBYM 3.33333E-6 -2.96296E-6 L 0.03333 0.18773 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB<B=<*D$' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?Dk' =.37 BBBBBEM 0 -2.96296E-6 L 0.03333 0.1875 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB<B=<* D:' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?D' =.I7 BBBBB[M -3.33333E-6 -3.98844E-6 L 0.03334 0.18729 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB<B-ǿ=<* D8' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?D' =.G7 BBBBBYM 3.33333E-6 -2.96296E-6 L -0.31667 0.2588 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB"""B><* D6' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?D}' =.E7 BBBBBWM 3.33333E-6 1.11111E-6 L 0.09166 0.18426 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB;=Bv=<*D4' =A@BB#BB0B%()?)?D{' =.C7 BBBBBUM 3.33333E-6 -2.59259E-6 L 0.15 -0.01389 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB=B9<*D8' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?D' =.G7 BBBBBYM 3.33333E-6 -1.85185E-6 L 0.20833 -0.0787 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBUU=Bh/!<* D:' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?D' =.I7 BBBBB[M 3.33333E-6 -4.44444E-6 L 0.26666 -0.21504 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB>Bqܽ<*&D2' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?Dy' =.A7 BBBBBSM -0.00417 -3.2948E-6 L 0.2625 -0.21156 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB>Bؽ<*'D8' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?D' =.G7 BBBBBYM -0.00834 -4.44444E-6 L -0.09167 -0.15347 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB*Bd<*(D:' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?D' =.I7 BBBBB[M 3.33333E-6 -4.44444E-6 L 0.09166 -0.22245 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB;=B<*)D8' =A@BB@BB0B%()?)?D' =.G7 BBBBBYM 3.33333E-6 -1.11111E-6 L 0.0875 -0.22014 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB333=BŨ<**D2' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?Dy' =.A7 BBBBBSM 3.33333E-6 0.14445 L 0.03333 -0.22222 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB<B;<*-D2' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?Dy' =.A7 BBBBBSM 3.33333E-6 0.14445 L 0.02916 -0.22222 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBn<B;<*.D.' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?Du' =.=7 BBBBBOM 3.33333E-6 0.14445 L 0.025 -0.22222 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBL<B;<*/D4' =A@BB@BB0B%()?)?D{' =.C7 BBBBBUM 3.33333E-6 -0.13101 L 0.20833 -0.42222 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBUU=B<*3D4' =A@BB@BB0B%()?)?D{' =.C7 BBBBBUM 3.33333E-6 -0.13333 L 0.20416 -0.42268 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB=B%<*4D,' =A@BB@BB0B%()?)?Ds' =.;7 BBBBBMM 3.33333E-6 -0.13333 L 0.2 -0.42268 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB=B%<*5D.' =A@BB8BB0B%()?)?Du' =.=7 BBBBBOM -0.00313 0.01112 L 0.02188 -0.35671 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBL<Bq<<*7D.' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?Du' =.=7 BBBBBOM 0.00834 1.11111E-6 L -0.125 0.31273 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBB ><*D.' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?Du' =.=7 BBBBBOM 0.00833 1.11111E-6 L -0.125 0.31782 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBB"><*D4' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?D{' =.C7 BBBBBUM 0.00833 -3.98844E-6 L -0.59167 0.45827 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBBԡj><*D:' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?D' =.I7 BBBBB[M 3.33333E-6 -2.22222E-6 L -0.35834 0.25672 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBww7BQ><*D0' =A@BB#BB0B%()?)?Dw' =.?7 BBBBBQM 3.33333E-6 1.48148E-6 L -0.3 0.06065 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBB1j<<*$D8' =A@BB#BB0B%()?)?D' =.G7 BBBBBYM -3.33333E-6 -0.00023 L -0.35833 -0.07824 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBww7B< <*+D6' =A@BB#BB0B%()?)?D}' =.E7 BBBBBWM 3.33333E-6 -0.00949 L -0.35834 -0.21944 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBww7B:׽<*2D"' =A@BB#BB0B%()?)?Di' =.17 BBBBBCM 0 -0.00231 L -0.1875 -0.28217 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBBLh<*9D,' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?Ds' =.;7 BBBBBMM 0.00417 1.11111E-6 L -0.475 0.4537 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBUUuBKh><* D.' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?Du' =.=7 BBBBBOM 0.00834 6.35838E-7 L -0.475 0.45503 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBwwwBh><* D.' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?Du' =.=7 BBBBBOM 0.00833 6.35838E-7 L -0.475 0.45503 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBwwwBh><*D8' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?D' =.G7 BBBBBYM 3.33333E-6 4.44444E-6 L -0.24167 0.38912 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBwwBrG><*D2' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?Dy' =.A7 BBBBBSM 0.00417 4.44444E-6 L -0.24167 0.38773 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBBffF><*D:' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?D' =.I7 BBBBB[M -3.33333E-6 4.44444E-6 L -0.24166 0.38912 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBwwBrG><*D:' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?D' =.I7 BBBBB[M 3.33333E-6 -4.44444E-6 L -0.59167 0.45371 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBwwBKh><*D4' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?D{' =.C7 BBBBBUM 0.00417 -2.22222E-6 L -0.41667 0.38727 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBwwWB)F><*D<' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?D' =.K7 BBBBB]M -3.33333E-6 -2.22222E-6 L -0.41666 0.38866 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBUUUBF><*D:' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?D' =.I7 BBBBB[M 3.33333E-6 -2.22222E-6 L -0.41667 0.38866 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBUUUBF><*D2' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?Dy' =.A7 BBBBBSM 0.00417 2.96296E-6 L -0.24167 0.32384 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBB[%><*D2' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?Dy' =.A7 BBBBBSM 0.05834 2.96296E-6 L -0.24166 0.32384 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBB[%><*D4' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?D{' =.C7 BBBBBUM -0.05834 2.96296E-6 L -0.59167 0.39051 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBB}G><*D2' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?Dy' =.A7 BBBBBSM 0.00417 -1.85185E-6 L -0.41667 0.3257 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBwwWB&><*D,' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?Ds' =.;7 BBBBBMM 0.05834 0.00509 L -0.35833 0.32477 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBUUUB9#><*D0' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?Dw' =.?7 BBBBBQM -0.05834 -1.85185E-6 L -0.475 0.3257 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBUUUB&><*!D2' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?Dy' =.A7 BBBBBSM 0.00417 1.48148E-6 L -0.24167 0.25393 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBBt><*"D:' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?D' =.I7 BBBBB[M -3.33333E-6 1.48148E-6 L -0.24166 0.25393 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBwwBt><*#D8' =A@BB#BB0B%()?)?D' =.G7 BBBBBYM 3.33333E-6 1.48148E-6 L -0.59167 0.32569 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBwwB&><*%D8' =A@BB@BB0B%()?)?D' =.G7 BBBBBYM 3.33333E-6 4.07407E-6 L -0.53334 0.18726 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBB=<*,D8' =A@BB#BB0B%()?)?D' =.G7 BBBBBYM -3.33333E-6 4.07407E-6 L -0.41666 0.1162 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBUUUB5m=<*0D:' =A@BB#BB0B%()?)?D' =.I7 BBBBB[M 3.33333E-6 -1.11111E-6 L -0.41667 0.12083 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBUUUBwww=<*1D4' =A@BB#BB0B%()?)?D{' =.C7 BBBBBUM 3.33333E-6 -1.85185E-6 L -0.3 -0.01342 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBBjۻ<*8D6' =A@BB#BB0B%()?)?D}' =.E7 BBBBBWM -3.33333E-6 -4.44444E-6 L -0.3 -0.01342 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBBjۻ<*6D ' =%(DK' =4@BBB B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*>%(D' =-6B+checkerboard(across)*<3<*>DX' =A@BBB B0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*@%(D' =-6B+checkerboard(across)*<3<*@DX' =A@BBB B0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*?%(D' =-6B+checkerboard(across)*<3<*?DX' =A@BBB B0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*=%(D' =-6B+checkerboard(across)*<3<*=Df ' =%(D6' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?D}' =.E7 BBBBBWM 3.33333E-6 2.96296E-6 L -0.3125 0.40046 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB B{ M><*:D4' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?D{' =.C7 BBBBBUM 3.33333E-6 2.96296E-6 L 0.2625 0.60347 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBBff>Bm><*;D4' =A@BB*BB0B%()?)?D{' =.C7 BBBBBUM 3.33333E-6 2.96296E-6 L 0.0375 0.76574 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB<B><*<DX' =A@BBB B0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*A%(D' =-6B+checkerboard(across)*<3<*AD' =%(D' =%(D@' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(D' =-o6Bwipe(up)*<3<*D' =%(D3' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(D' =-o6Bwipe(up)*<3<*+ +0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+ 0 ++0+ 0 ++0+ 0 ++0+ 0 ++0+ 0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+ 0 ++0+!0 ++0+"0 ++0+#0 ++0+$0 ++0+%0 ++0+&0 ++0+'0 ++0+(0 ++0+)0 ++0+*0 ++0++0 ++0+,0 ++0+-0 ++0+.0 ++0+/0 ++0+00 ++0+10 ++0+20 ++0+30 ++0+40 ++0+50 ++0+60 ++0+70 ++0+80 ++0+90 ++0+:0 ++0+;0 ++0+<0 ++0+=0 ++0+?0 ++0+@0 ++0+A0 +v0 0H(  H H < C"?@@ Y!Equivalence Methodology Comments""H H 0޽h ? 33___PPT10i.:j+D='  = @B +E 0 \ T  (  b  s * S"     Detailed Methodology is vague on key proceduresBB J  S  `0   d OECD/DAC baseline indicators are substantially more ambiguous than current ICB Guidelines; even  critical indicators do not require the same degree of rigor as the current ICB Guidelines OECD/DAC v.4 lacks meaningful operational assessment tools or methodology Unclear how OECD/DAC v. 4 Benchmarking Tool will be applied or how it will be validated (NB: Will it remain a country self-assessment and self-validation as it is today?) Unclear why only a select few deficiencies require improvement through a Capacity Development Plan. Further the deficiencies will be included in the loan agreement only post-effectiveness. Today, loan agreements are withheld by the Bank pending effectiveness and are not easily available to the public, if at all, on Bank s website. Unclear why certain sub-indicators are  critical meaning required to qualify for pilot, others are  critical but not required to qualify for pilot, and others  non-critical d0P20_2;H  0޽h ? 33___PPT10i./+D='  = @B +0 <|(  <0 < 6    Detailed Methodology is vague on key proceduresBB   < 0  0 @ tUnclear how the Bank s CPAR, NCB Side Letter, and OECD/DAC assessments are factored into a measurement of  equivalence Lacks comprehensive details of the  step-by-step analysis to determine  equivalence (who is involved, how it proceeds, how it is assessed and validated, and to whom testing results will be made available) Unspecified time frame for implementation of agreed upon Capacity Development Plan or guidance regarding assessment and validation No evident procedures for assessing progress required by the Loan Agreement, or specifics should a country fail to take effective actions. No detail provided for new project risk assessment or capacity assessment tools and methodology0P2H < 0޽h ? 33___PPT10i.q: D+D='  = @B +0 `0(  H  0޽h ? 33___PPT10i.M;h]+D='  = @B +I 0^N0   =4z (  48  `  4 ` ZB 4 s *D33Ԕ   ZB 4 s *D33Ԕ `ZB 4 s *D33Ԕ  ZB 4 s *D33Ԕ``0 ZB 4 s *D33Ԕ 0 `0 ZB  4 s *D33Ԕ 0  64 6\ ,` ~FSummary: ICB Guidelines Acceptably Covered by Required Sub-IndicatorsG(2G$ 74 6 ,$0 _)GL 2.7-2.8: Notification and Advertising** 2* 84 6@0~,$0 MGL 1.10: Joint Ventures 2 94 6D#  ,$ 0 RGL 2.43: Dispute Settlement* 2 :4 6# pY ,$0 t>GL 1.15: Fraud Provisions / Bid Documents of Large Contracts**? 2? ;4 6#q,$0 MGL 1.12: Misprocurement 2 <4 6 @,$0 @ 2  =4 6#  ,$0 ]'GL 2.19-2.20: Standards and Brand Names( 2(H 4 0޽h ? 33___PPT10.Pa+>D'  = @B D' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +D' =%(D' =%(D0' =4@BBBB%(D' =0l9 CCBB*<3<*4D' =%(D' =%(D' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*=4%(D' =%(D' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*:4%(D' =%(D' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*74%(D' =%(D' =K@BBBBPB0B%(/%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*<4%(D' =%(D' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*84%(D' =%( D' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*;4%(D' =%( D' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*94%(++0+740 ++0+840 ++0+940 ++0+:40 ++0+;40 ++0+<40 ++0+=40 + A 0^N0 ,,0>B0 :,(  2  6)  ,$D02  6)0,$D02  6) ,$D02  6) ,$D 02  6)@p,$D 02  6) H,$D 02  6),$D02  6) 0n",$D0  6,+#@ @ 2 8  B  6A`, ~FSummary: ICB Guidelines Acceptably Covered by Required Sub-IndicatorsG(2G$`B   0D33)`B   0D33)`B   0D33)`B  0D33) `B  0D33) `B  0D33)    6/#  _)GL 2.7-2.8: Notification and Advertising** 2*  64#@0~ MGL 1.10: Joint Ventures 2  6 9#    RGL 2.43: Dispute Settlement* 2  6<#p Y  t>GL 1.15: Fraud Provisions / Bid Documents of Large Contracts**? 2?  6$A#q MGL 1.12: Misprocurement 2  6D#  ]'GL 2.19-2.20: Standards and Brand Names( 2(8 8H! ?8H!T  0! # 8H!f  6) 0!  0I#  }%ICB Guidelines NOT Acceptably Covered<& 2$$$  6 O# k1GL 1.3-1.4: Appropriate International Procurement2(22  6$S# x QGL 1.6-1.8: Eligibility(2  6L# SGL 1.16: Procurement Plan(2   6d[#(Vv SGL 2.6: Two-Stage Bidding(2 ! 6x_#@ ` b(GL 2.9-2.10: Prequalification of Bidders)(2) " 6c# o5GL 2.11-2.12: General Principles of Bidding Documents6(26 # 6h#17 a'GL 2.13-2.14: Bid Validity and Security((2( $ 6k#HH! KGL 2.15: Language(2 % 6p#H H! d*GL 2.16-2.18: Clarity of Bidding Documents+(2+ & 6t#,L OGL 2.21-2.23: Pricing(2 ' 6w#  XGL 2.24-2.25: Price Adjustment(2 ( 6{# d*GL 2.26-2.27: Transportation and Insurance+(2+ ) 6#0  [!GL 2.28-2.33: Currency Provisions"(2" * 6#  XGL 2.34-2.36: Terms of Payment(2 + 6#  YGL 2.38: Conditions of Contract (2  , 6#X \"GL 2.39-2.40: Performance Security#(2# - 6#z  g-GL 2.41: Liquidated Damages and Bonus Clauses.(2. . 6̓#( _%GL 2.44: Time for Preparation of Bids&(2& / 6ԗ# YGL 2.45: Bid Opening Procedures (2  0 6̛# h.GL 2.46: Clarifications or Alterations of Bids/(2/ 1 6#(v  SGL 2.37: Alternative Bids(2 2 6أ#_PV i/GL 2.49-2.54: Evaluation and Comparison of Bids0(20 3 6#1 \"GL 2.55-2.56: Domestic Preferences#(2# 4 6# a'GL 2.57: Extension and Validity of Bids((2( 5 6ܯ# vGL 2.58: Postqualification(2  6 6@#u { TGL 2.59: Award of Contract(2 7 60# ]#GL 2.61-2.64: Rejection of All Bids$(2$ 8 6X#  MGL 2.65: Debriefing(2 9 6p#/ P RGL 2.47: Confidentiality(2 : 6#  SGL Appendix 3: Complaints(2 ; 6#\4 rGL 2.42: Force Majeure(2 < 6# "  `&GL 2.2-2.5: Type and Size of Contracts'(2' = 6#H   UGL 1.9: Advance Contracting(2 > 6#+? WGL 1.14: Fraud and Corruption(2H  0޽h ? 33___PPT10.Pa+gD'  = @B DY' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +D' =%(D' =%(D0' =4@BBBB%(D' =0l9  B BBB*<3<*BD0' =4@BBBB%(D' =0l9 HBHBBB*<3<*?Dp' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<* %(D' =%( D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(D' =%(pD' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(+c 0^N0 @ 8(  F  `    ZB  s *D33Ԕ   ZB  s *D33Ԕ `ZB  s *D33Ԕ  ZB  s *D33Ԕ``0 ZB  s *D33Ԕ 0 `0 ZB  s *D33Ԕ 0 ^  6)H  0޽h ? 33KC___PPT10#.T Г+D' = @B D' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +D' =%(%(Dq' =%(D' =4@BB8BB%()?)?Dm' =.57 BBBBBGM 0 3.78353E-6 L -0.30764 -0.3358 *3>*B ppt_xB ppt_y=@0BBAApBB؂B+<*+  0^N0   HW (  HF  `  H ZB H s *D33Ԕ   ZB H s *D33Ԕ `ZB H s *D33Ԕ  ZB H s *D33Ԕ``0 ZB H s *D33Ԕ 0 `0 ZB H s *D33Ԕ 0   H B#) : x  H 033C"?x  H 033C"? H 0LsZ : 2  H 0#  ^&ICB guidelines acceptably covered 12%' 2'f H 0#  d*ICB guidelines NOT acceptably covered 88%+(2+ PP H 0 $ 5Conclusions The 2007 methodology for assessing laws / regulations does not improve upon the withdrawn 2005 proposal. The proposal offers no methodology to assess day-to-day operational procurement practices. The proposal does not measure equivalence with current Bank procurement rules and practice. Essential elements of the proposal are omitted (compliance and risk assessment tools) | (2{ 2 ;@8XH H 0޽h ? 33___PPT10i.T Г+D='  = @B + 0 zr (    c $ $ ` <$@0 $   0L$  : 2 R  00R `,$ 0 A step backwards in effective and accountable international procurement Counter to good governance and sustainable economic growth(2B  s *D>  ,$@0  00 @ ,$0 B 2H   0 $  {3The 2007 Proposal for Country Systems Pilot Program4(24    0P*$ ,$0 9= 2HH  0޽h ? 33 ___PPT10.S@C+D'  = @B D' = @BA?%,( < +O%,( < +D' =%(D' =%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*L%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*L%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*#%(D)' =%(D' =%(D' =K@BBBBPB0B%(/%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(D' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(D' =4@BBBB%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(D' =A@BBBB0B%(D' =1:Bvisible*o3>+B#style.visibility<*%(++0+0 ++0+0 ++0+0 +$0 f^(  ^  S hRH   $X  c $$h !~  $f^___PPT9@8 ~VCited Documents: 2006. Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness. Available at http://www.oecd.org/ OECD. 2007. Integrity in Public Procurement: Good Practice from A to Z. Available at http://www.oecd.org/ OECD. 2007. Bribery in Public Procurement: Methods, Actors and Countermeasures. Available at http://www.oecdbookshop.org/ " " "  &5;%B.  >X d kH  0jB ? 3380___PPT10.1@WCF %0   V (  ^  S hRH   $   c $$h !  $ L Reference Documents: 2A: EVALUATION OF DETAILED METHODOLOGY FOR PROCUREMENT COUNTRY SYSTEMS PILOTING PROGRAM (SEPTEMBER 2007) BASELINE INDICATORS AND COMPARISON TO WORLD BANK GUIDELINES TO PROCUREMENT UNDER IBRD AND IDA CREDITS (OCTOBER 2006) Corresponding sub-indicators are: Use the Bank s Standard Bidding Documents for international tenders (2E) Adhere to Bank norms on fraud and corruption (12B) Show a strong anti-corruption enforcement record (12C) Reveal deficiencies in its procurement system until after a Loan Agreement has been executed (n/a) Make Codes of Conduct / Ethics obligatory or enforceable (12G) Make public procurement information publicly available free of charge and both comprehensive and easy to understand (11A) Conduct effective data collection, analysis and reporting (5B) Ensure that country procurement personnel are competitively selected on the basis of procurement knowledge and skills (6A) Ensure that compliance auditors are sufficiently informed about procurement to conduct quality audits that contribute to compliance or that they regularly report issues to management (9C, 9E) nb  E D 4  " J  H  0jB ? 3380___PPT10.3k '0 D <  (   ^   S hRH   $6   c $$h !  $ nReference Documents: 2A: EVALUATION OF DETAILED METHODOLOGY FOR PROCUREMENT COUNTRY SYSTEMS PILOTING PROGRAM (SEPTEMBER 2007) BASELINE INDICATORS AND COMPARISON TO WORLD BANK GUIDELINES TO PROCUREMENT UNDER IBRD AND IDA CREDITS (OCTOBER 2006) Corresponding sub-indicators are: Make all procurement information publicly available free of charge and both comprehensive and easy to understand (5B) Specify time frames for disseminating procurement information (invitations, procurement notices or awards) (5A) Conduct comprehensive procurement data management, analysis and auditing (4B, 5B) Use or regulate model tender documents  where documents exist, they are only required to contain a minimum set of clauses (2B) Regularly update and make transparent implementing regulations for country procurement systems (2A) Possess a procurement manual for contracting entities (2E) Harmonize its document retention policy with international standards (6C)@ED4H   0jB ? 3380___PPT10.6 (0 ia(  ^  S hRH   $[  c $$h !  $ qReference Documents: 2A: EVALUATION OF DETAILED METHODOLOGY FOR PROCUREMENT COUNTRY SYSTEMS PILOTING PROGRAM (SEPTEMBER 2007) BASELINE INDICATORS AND COMPARISON TO WORLD BANK GUIDELINES TO PROCUREMENT UNDER IBRD AND IDA CREDITS (OCTOBER 2006) Corresponding sub-indicators are: Expressly state all evaluation criteria and stipulate lowest evaluated cost as the sole award criteria (1F) Provide a clear method for evaluating non-price criteria in goods and works tenders (1F) Specify the amount of time for bid preparation (1C) Supply prospective bidders with all information pertaining to a bid (1E) Ensure that all pre-qualified applicants are allowed to bid (2C) Supply all bidders with the record of bid opening and explicitly deny bids received after the close date or not read publicly (1G) Guarantee formal recourse for complaints to an independent body such as the World Bank (1H) Specify in advance in the bid documents how currency and payment will be handled (1E) Provide an express methodology for assessing bids where technical capacity is a core component and integrating non-price assessments into the bid evaluation (2D) br  E D 4  " [ H  0jB ? 3380___PPT10.70Zt0 \T (  ^  S hRH   $N  c $$h !  $ Reference Documents: 2B: COVERAGE OF WORLD BANK GUIDELINES TO PROCUREMENT UNDER IBRD LOANS AND IDA CREDITS BY 2007 COUNTRY SYSTEMS PROPOSAL BASELINE INDICATORS$2;6H  0jB ? 3380___PPT10.99$ ?0   pX4 (  Xd X c $hRH   $  X s *&h !`  $H@___PPT9" Reference Documents: World Bank. Guidelines to Procurement under IBRD Loans and IDA Credits. October 2006. Available at http://www.worldbank.org UNCITRAL. Model Law on Procurement of Goods, Construction and Services. 1994. Available at http://www.uncitral.org UN. Convention of the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards ( New York Convention ). 1958. Available at http://uncitral.org WTO. Plurilateral Agreement on Government Procurement. 1996. Available at http://www.wto.org World Bank. Standard Bidding Documents. Revised 2007. Available at http://www.worldbank.org Cited Documents: World Bank. 2007. Detailed Methodology for Procurement Country Systems Piloting Program. Available at http://go.worldbank.org/KB821V1X10 OECD. 2006. New Common Benchmarking and Assessment Methodology for Public Procurement Systems (Version 4). Available at http://www.oecd.org C" " "  :C<4HI068E# \%f  B M H X 0jB ? 3380___PPT10.2 @-r  w"( (0gc+, (/0a3 ?6R8?:@-{G8"C@6 DR0mIe_K}M%R2uV v*H0V1Oh+'0 `h  OECD/DAC v. 4: Four pillars wb97842458Microsoft Office PowerPoint@PmWg@`d@L?bq Gg  B  yf--$xx--'--$)BB))--'@Arial-. 2 5 World Bank ."Systemp;-@Arial-.  2 5(.-@Arial-. ?2 5+%Detailed Methodology for Procurement .-@Arial-. 72 < Country Systems Piloting Program.-@Arial-.  2 <x.-@Arial-. 2 <}(2007).-@Arial-. *2 Y4Evaluation and Comments.-@Arial-. 2 a=10 December 2007.-@Arial-. B2 o2'Development Finance International, Inc..-՜.+,0T  $ , On-screen Show$Development Finance International81 ArialDefault DesignZWorld Bank Detailed Methodology for Procurement Country Systems Piloting Program (2007)Slide 2Slide 3Slide 4Slide 5Slide 6Slide 7@Fails to articulate and encourage international best practicesNReduces transparency and accountability, increasing probability of corruptionSUndermines reliability, transparency, and accessibility of procurement informationCDecreases protections for bidders in bidding and tendering process Slide 12 Slide 13 Slide 14BDetailed Methodology is vague on key procedures Slide 16 Slide 17 Slide 18 Slide 19 Slide 20 Slide 21 Slide 22  Fonts UsedDesign Template Slide Titles_1wb97842wb97842  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~      !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root EntrydO)Current UserSummaryInformation(PowerPoint Document(81DocumentSummaryInformation8